This article was originally published at RealMoney on November 5, 2007.
Dassault Systemes (DASTY) is trading down nearly 6% after the company trimmed its earnings outlook by five Eurocents last week. The company now expects to earn between €1.96 and €2.00 in 2007, compared with earlier guidance of €2.00 – €2.05. With a solid overall business and a valuation that I believe looks reasonable, I think investors will ultimately find today’s price to have been an excellent entry point.
Dassault designs engineering software used for Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) (81% of 2006 revenue) and Mainstream 3-D design (19%). It has grown through organic growth and a series of acquisitions, including Abaqus in 2005 and MatrixOne in 2006 – each of which was in the order of $500 million consideration. It is 44.5% owned and effectively controlled by
Dassault offers software under several brands, including Solidworks for Mainstream 3D design and CATIA, DELMIA, SIMULIA and ENOVIA for PLM. However, a key aspect of its growth strategy is to combine the strengths of its various programs and allow customers to customize solutions using the company’s V5 platform.
The company generates 47% of its revenue in Europe, 31% in the
More than half of the company’s sales are on a recurring (software rental or maintenance contract) basis rather than through perpetual license fees. With a largely industrial customer base, revenue growth drivers include business investment and industrial production in its end markets.
Competition
Dassault lists its primary PLM competitors as Parametric (PMTC) and Unigraphics, which was recently acquired by Siemens (SI). Its main competitor in Mainstream 3D is Autodesk (ADSK). The company also competes with Ansys (ANSS), Agile (AGIL), MSC Software (a href="http://stockmarketbeat.com/blog1/category/msc-software-mscs/">MSCS - Annual Report) and to a lesser extent Oracle (ORCL - Annual Report) and SAP (SAP - Annual Report).
The combined revenue of the nearest competitors and comparables, which I believe to be Dassault, Ansys, MSC and Parametric, has been approximately 11% annually over the last decade. Dassault has used its acquisitions and the opportunities provided by the V5 platform to grow at a faster rate than its peers.
In 2006 Dassault grew 24%, much of which was contributed by the Abaqus and MatrixOne acquisitions. On an organic basis sales grew 10% (12% assuming constant currency exchange rates.)
Risks
As I see it, the greatest risk Dassault faces is loss of a major customer. Although the company cites a customer base of 100,000 just 20 of those account for 25% of sales, with the largest customer accounting for 5%.
A potentially greater, though probably less likely risk is the company’s long-standing relationship with International Business Machines (IBM - Annual Report). IBM has a non-exclusive distribution relationship with Dassault and accounted for 45% of sales in 2006, so a rift between the companies could have a serious impact. The companies renegotiated the partnership earlier this year such that Dassault is taking responsibility for mid-market customers and IBM will serve enterprise customers. However, this adds a new risk related to maintaining a larger sales force.
Valuation
Dassault current market cap is approximately $7.3 billion, and with net cash on hand of nearly half a billion its enterprise value is about $6.8 billion. Given that it is on track to exceed its 2006 free cash flow generation of $300 million, the free cash flow yield of 4.4% compares favorably to the yield on five-year treasuries, and the 10% growth rate of recent years looks like a nice inducement for taking on the added risk.
By some common measures (5x book value and a P/E in the mid-20’s) the stock doesn’t exactly look like a bargain. But these measures overlook the cash flow generating power available to software companies. With essentially fixed costs and high margins, each dollar of sales contributes mightily to cash.
Although a recession or slowdown in Dassault’s key end markets or further dollar weakening could delay investor rewards, Dassault’s current valuation and long-term prospects appear to justify the wait.
Disclosure: Short naked put options on Ansys (ANSS)